I had written the following in my blog post announcing my departure from Amazon:
I am hiring a CEDIA-level installer to completely refit my home automation system and I will project manage that.
A few weeks ago someone at Control4 tweeted the following, which I replied to with a tweetstorm. This post expands on the idea I presented in that tweetstorm…
Even Charlie Kindel who brought Amazon Alexa to market, with all his technological experience and resources, he's still underwhelmed with the way his smart home is functioning today. Give #DIY a rest! #C4Yourself what real #smarthome #luxury looks like. https://t.co/tU8fuvLbV3
— Control4 (@Control4) May 9, 2018
This is true. Even though smart homes are finally taking off, after decades of fits and starts, I still think most of the do-it-yourself (DIY) smart home products are too hard to use and too fragile to actually depend on. There’s still a HUGE gap between a home professionally outfitted top-to-bottom and a home with a bunch of DIY gadgets cobbled together by the home owner.
Not everyone can afford a professionally designed, installed, programmed, and monitored smart home.
If they can afford it today, I recommend to friends they go the “Concierge” route: Hire a professional home technology integrator to just do it all for you, correctly. Life is too short to spend futzing around configuring and programming your home.
This not only applies to useful gadgets like lights, media, and cameras, but to the network infrastructure that needs to be in place for it all to work. Ask yourself this: How much of your own personal time would you budget if you decided to replace your home router? The last person I asked this said “At least a weekend.”
If you react to this by saying “Oh, I use Foo Co’s product and it’s so easy it’ll just take an hour” you are either…
- living in a one bedroom apartment,
- have no idea what it means to have a fully outfitted smart home, or
- extremely lucky for now, try adding 10+ more diverse devices.
The infrastructure in my home is dated (we designed and built the house in 1999-2002) and I’m going pay a pro to refit everything in the next few months. By everything I mean home network infrastructure, lighting, whole home music, televisions, security, cameras, irrigation, HVAC, and intercom/telephone. There will be some DIY products involved, but the infrastructure and automation system will be designed, installed, programmed, and monitored by a professional, not me.
I currently have over 250 ‘devices’ controllable by Alexa in my home. 152 of those are lighting loads. 47 are keypads. Some are virtual devices like scenes. Some are devices like the air compressor in my workshop which only powers on when I’m there. We have five TVs with associated media players and speakers. There’s an 8-zone whole-home audio system. Plus the security system and cameras. It took serious work by me to program it and maintain it over the past 17 years, all as a hobby. It works, but not as well as it could and should. Part of this is because some of the tech is old, but it’s mostly because I’m not a pro. I don’t get paid to do this.
I do not want to spend my time programming my home anymore. I want to spend that time on my cars . I’ve lived in homes with professionally outfitted systems, similar in scale to mine, and the stability, refinement, and ease of use really does deliver on the dream many of us in the industry have been working towards for decades.
However, not even the high-end stuff (or industry) is perfect. Some old-school incumbents have intentionally made their products complex to artificially support dealer networks and protect crazy margins. Some do a horrible job interfacing with other companies’ products. There are not enough skilled installers and programmers, which is limiting growth. And it’s all pretty expensive – everyone in the value-chain wants their fair share and the value-chain is deep.
Part of why I want to have a pro do it this time is to see how far away we (the collective smart home industry) are from the ideal. The ideal being a world where anyone can afford a completely connected smart home where professionals design, install, program, and monitor the infrastructure, devices, and system so customers can just enjoy the benefits. I call this “Concierge Home Technology”.
Concierge Home Technology is real today, and is big business. Technology companies like Savant Systems, Control4, Snap A/V, Crestron, and Lutron are the players you’ve probably heard of. They are supported by tens of thousands of dealer/integrators around the world who do the design, installation, programming, and monitoring. If you are considering making your home truly smart, in order to have music everywhere, reliable voice-controlled lighting, great security, and automatic behaviors find a local dealer/integrator and ask them to show you an ‘experience-based’ demo home (Control4 just launched a cool initiative where at least one of their dealers in every major city has a certified showroom).
The Big 5 are all investing big time in smart home products. A few of them are actually making real money at it (finally). Their focus is on DIY products, and they generally believe smart homes can be self-organizing (by software). I don’t buy it. No household of any size, with more than few family members, is ever going to have the level of refinement and sophistication mine has without some custom programming. I’m eager to see how this plays out.
I think those are spot on points – Time is Money. By doing it yourself you are wasting your own money, which you can invest somewhere else a.k.a cars. I am mean seriously I can’t even get my Nest Thermostats to function right.
I agree. I made the same argument to Microsoft when i was in their IoT team.
How did I miss this? I made some analogies a few years ago about hiring an Ikea assembly guy to install my $79 dressers. He did it all correctly, with no leftover pieces, in record time. I typically have a handful of pieces left over, one shelf backwards, welts on my shins, and a few days wasted … plus dressers that fall apart in 8.5 months.
As a control4 user I can agree with a lot of this article- however it all depends on how go your installer is.
Also Control4 are using DIY products within its software – Phillip Hue, Sonos, Doorbird, Yale Locks etc
I agree with this. Concierge Home Technology can provide the convenience that I want.
The reason DIY is around is due to money. It is not the cause of wasting money. I received two quotes for adding three sensors and a switch to a control4 system without any programming: $900, all remote work. I believe dealers should get paid for the value they bring, and so should the companies, but this level will always push people to the DIY for $150 or less.